Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by markdown 2340 days ago
Mice aren't "beings".
3 comments

The point is mice are life forms. Who are we as humans to decide what that means for them?
> Who are we as humans to decide what that means for them?

Is that a joke? Rats, cockroaches, and mosquitoes are all life forms. Poison ivy is a life form. Guinea worms are life forms.

We as intelligent beings get to decide what it all means. We can crush them, we can use them to our advancement, or we can set them up as gods and worship them.

But none of those things are beings. It's our language, and we , not mice, get to decide what the word "being" means.

It's not a joke. It's a frank question. We might decide what the word "being" means to us, but that doesn't change the reality of what the word is pointing to.
Noun

being (countable and uncountable, plural beings)

A living creature.

Nope. That's not how it's defined. A guinea worm is also a living creature, as is a mosquito, but they aren't beings. Beings is used to refer to intelligent life.
Then who is?
Humans. I confess, I have no ability to understand the powerful empathy people feel for rodents. I really feel nothing for them.