Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 2Xheadpalm 2344 days ago
The wolf has and is still persecuted by man, mainly for perceived financial and political reasons today but the negative propaganda and irrational emotion from the middle ages and beyond still lingers in the general population...

https://www.wolfawareness.org/issues

I live in wolf country and in the winter have seen formed packs of 15 or more wolves doing the rounds on my property. If I am out and about walking in that woodlands it is something to be aware of and like any wildlife should be treated with care and respect but moments of brief fear and potential, rare danger is not a reason to eliminate them mercilessly.

This country is also ranching country and yes, every year, ranchers loose cattle to predators such as wolves, cougars and grizzly bear, our neighbors lost 1 cow and had another seriously injured from a wolf pack early this winter. I can appreciate their desire to protect their livelihoods and bovine charges but when it comes to wolves the response to these incidents, many times is motivated with extreme prejudice and their counter measure responses typically far disproportionaly outweigh the losses for a year.

2 comments

I agree with you that modern outrage about wolf reintroduction is probably misplaced but I'd be hesitant about dismissing historical reactions.

If you're a subsistence farmer (of which there were many in the middle ages) losing a cow a year might mean starvation. And I'd wager there were more wolves around back then.

Eradication was a short sited policy, but maybe not irrational.

In modern times we have more problems with feral hogs. They will root up and destroy acres and acres of crops. They're also incredibly quick to multiply as they can breed year round and have about 2 litters a year at 5-6 piglets per litter. In many states it's legal to hunt hogs year round as a result.
The thing I would say is not all reintroduction programs are the same, and just generalizing "wolves" to all of them is a mistake. I grew up in a reintro area and the changes have not been for the better, but I sat down and read the scientific paper used as the justification and ours was shitty science compared to, say Yellowstones reintro program.
The red wolf reintroduction in eastern NC was not popular among land owners. The population has declined from more than 100 in 2012 to fewer than 14:

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2015/03/150318-red-w...

https://apnews.com/d8a127176390cecf79b7d2b3b8893046