[paranoidrobot]

I'm not sure what you're trying to say.

Moral rights are quite distinct from copy rights.

[TylerE]

Fundamental to moral rights is control over over how the work is marketed or presented. My OP did not make any claims at all WRT to copyright.

[paranoidrobot]

"I'd argue that pirating games that aren't available anywhere should not be illegal. "

The only reason that I can see that this would be illegal would be due to copyrights.

I don't think they're arguing that the original author/publisher shouldn't recieve attribution and credit for the original work.

If someone was originally selling a product openly, and they now no longer choose to do so - then they're effectively abandoning their interest in those copyrights. Sharing those abandoned items shouldn't be illegal.