[Traster]

'Crappy' and 'Hacked-together' are literally just insults, they don't carry real technical criticism and frankly they just continue to undermine the credibility of the author. The fact is that 'crappy' code is the most used http crate by far. Clearly everyone in the rust community must be an idiot to be using it. I'm sure the author went off and wrote a totally safe replacement for it. See, now we all get to be dicks to each other rather than actually working to fix stuff.

[zozbot234]

The first step in working to fix stuff is being aware of the issues - there's nothing "insulting" about that. Unsafe blocks without any clearly-stated rationale and safety analysis is quite subpar quality. Just because it's common and a "most used crate" does not make it OK, leftpad was widely used too.

[dnorman]

_It's not what you say but how you say it_

With all due respect, you are not the universal arbiter of "crappy"-ness and "hacked-together"-ness, nor is anybody else. My guess is that you have concerns about the library, and you are absolutely within your right to say so. Your concerns may even have significant substance to them; or perhaps there is additional perspective that could change your mind.

Unfortunately, presenting your view and judgement as a statement of objective fact not only shuts down potentially valid counter-argumentation, but it's also inflammatory/insultory because it misrepresents your agency in the situation, and diminishes the efforts/personhood of those who contributed to the library.

It's understandable that you might want to use such phrasing as short-hand from time to time, but saying it out loud, especially in a public venue is regrettably demonstrative of a lack of self-awareness. It drowns out your message regardless of its merit, and pushes other people away. It's a reductive way of thinking, and it does everybody (including yourself) a disservice.

In the words of Groucho Marx "I don't want to belong to any club that would have me as a member."

We could all choose be sour and jaded, fighting over scraps in a futile search for self-worth –OR– we could each take it upon ourselves to be the standard-bearers of what was, and hopefully will remain, a warm and inviting place for meritorious debate. I choose the latter.