Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Jenz 2347 days ago
I would love to see the reviewer report.
3 comments
doodpants 2347 days ago
The article that modernerd linked to has links at the bottom, in the "Appendix". The reviewer report is here: https://scholarlyoa.files.wordpress.com/2014/11/review-form....
link
jeltz 2347 days ago
I love how everything other than the presentation is either Excellent or Very Good while the presentation is just Good.
link
kaybe 2347 days ago
https://scholarlyoa.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/reviewer-...

I'm not sure whether that's the full report though.

link
mcv 2347 days ago
The real review is better than my made-up review. The reviewer is probably intimately familiar with the problem described by the article's author.
link
TallGuyShort 2347 days ago
If I was being spammed to review articles and saw this come through, I might be a little tempted to rubber-stamp it.
link
mcv 2347 days ago
"The article makes a convincing argument that is supported by the data."
link