Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by phillipsjk 2355 days ago
Scaling with second layers instead of on-chain is NOT "sound engineering"

The Engineering discipline relies on empirical studies. With constantly full blocks, you have no way to measure transaction demand.

Fees are only a weak indicator of transaction demand because of substitute goods.
1 comments
marcinjachymiak 2355 days ago
A great empirical study you should pursue is initial blockchain download time with (full) 2000 MB blocks and low-grade consumer hardware.
link
freeAgent 2355 days ago
People have already done this and it is quite fast! https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/ek0614/current_node_im...

Flowee the Hub (Bitcoin Cash full node implementation) can sync the equivalent of 4GB blocks using just a cheap quad-core VPS.

link
nullc 2355 days ago
Amusingly enough ... The rates there are, in fact, significantly slower than what plain old Bitcoin developers. Bitcoin dev's probably should make the syncing status print the number of inputs per second being processed.

But being able to barely keep up means that if you fall behind for even a moment (say, if your connection drops... or if miners get lucky and mine a bunch of extra blocks) then you will _never_ catch up. Operating anywhere near the limit of your processing rate is non-viable for that reason.

You need to be able to process many times the network's capacity so that you can catch up in a reasonable amount of time.

link
freeAgent 2354 days ago
Sure, but OP said 2GB. A node able to process 4GB blocks would be able to sync at 2x realtime. Most people who run nodes will probably bootstrap new ones in the future anyway and most people don't need to run full nodes in the first place (the majority don't do so today and haven't since light wallets became available).

To get back to reality, I don't think any sane person has advocated for anything close to a 2GB blocksize cap at any point in the near future. Bitcoin Core uses a maximum 4MB block weight and Bitcoin Cash uses a 32MB cap currently. This cheap VPS could sync the entire Bitcoin (Core) blockchain from 2009 to present in less than 12 hours. The biggest block size cap (not full blocks, the cap) being tested seriously is 1GB. I'm sure you know all this, though.

link