Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jcims 2362 days ago
The problem is 'begs the question' is not an intuitive phrase to describe the formal definition, so we're going to be stuck with this correction forever.

At this point I feel it has only survived as a form of shibboleth.

2 comments

You’d think that, but we pedants managed to rescue the word “ironic” at one point.
But you've figuratively lost "literally".
That's just highly advanced irony; using the word "literally" non-literally.
>The problem is 'begs the question' is not an intuitive phrase to describe the formal definition

it does if you look at the etymology; beg comes begging off i.e. asking for exemption from something. it's archaic at this point of course but still fairly intelligible in that use; "he begged off doing his chores".