Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Misdicorl 2360 days ago
Only if the 2nd law of thermodynamics holds. When speculating about advanced civilizations building Dyson spheres, why not speculate about the bedrock of science as well?

There are (probably) other paths to avoiding this conundrum as well. Spitballing here, but perhaps the 'satellites' in this case can be pairs of orbiting black holes which emit the waste heat in a band we don't detect (gravitational waves).
2 comments
pharke 2360 days ago
I always forget about the concept of gravitational engineering, probably because it's just a bit scary to think about the unknowns involved. If you could mass produce small black holes and position them you could pretty easily construct giant lenses capable of redirecting the output of a star to anywhere you please. That's more than a little terrifying.
link
ailideex 2360 days ago
> Only if the 2nd law of thermodynamics holds. When speculating about advanced civilizations building Dyson spheres, why not speculate about the bedrock of science as well?

If the person I replied to qualified their comment with "lets assume laws of physicis is not relevant" then sure...

link
Misdicorl 2360 days ago
Except when discussing technologically hyper advanced civilizations, the 2nd law of thermodynamics is a (vaguely) reasonable place to expect our laws to break.

The 2nd law is an observed fact with very shaky theoretical underpinnings (I am not talking about the behavior which has very strong underpinnings). It appears to be an emergent behavior rather than a fundamental one. It is a surprising fact given what else we know about the universe. It breaks the time symmetry of the other laws of physics. This is akin to learning that even though the laws of physics dont break position and rotational symmetries, there is a preferred direction and spin. In fact there is a preferred spin- all neutrinos are left handed. There are huge research efforts to understand why or if there are corresponding right handed particles. Broken symmetries mean big things because as far as we can tell the universe is ruled by what symmetries exist and in what ways they are broken.

link