Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by derefr 2370 days ago
There's no reason that Thunderbolt (especially optical Thunderbolt) can't be that standard. In fact, there's no reason that Thunderbolt controllers need to live in the CPU, rather than living on PCi-e HBA cards (like InfiniBand or RAID controllers do.)

It just hasn't happened yet because of a lack of enterprise demand. The pendulum hasn't swung back to all-externalizing blade servers quite yet.

1 comments

Actually they currently just put a retimer chip on the backplane, attach the NVMe drives to the otherwise passive (as far as high-speed data goes) backplane, and use QSFP+ twinax cabling between the backplane and a sometimes passive "HBA" card that adapts from PCIe slot to this QSFP+ cage. Afaik they can run PCIe3 x4 per cable. If you look for open compute hardware, you'll find various modular blade-like designs.