Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by krupan 2378 days ago
Do we all feel better blaming the tech companies for this than blaming ourselves, the customers of the tech companies?
2 comments

Uh, yes? You can force millions of consumers to stop buying things or a single company to stop producing them.

Which one is easier?

I mean, it's not just one company, is it? But it is less than than millions, so your point probably still stands.

Forcing anyone to do anything is pretty hard though. The U.S. government can lean on U.S. companies, but will that really save the child miners? Will they all suddenly not be forced into this type of labor if the U.S. companies stop using their services? Those kids will suddenly all be enrolled in school and grow up to be business owners, doctors, nurses, engineers, all using cell phones powered by some much more ethically obtained energy storage device?

I must be feeling down today. Sorry about that.

I feel the same when I think about how bleak this all is, but this could be one part of a multipart solution. No, it's not going to magically fix everything wrong with the global economy. But we have to think about things like corporate responsibility and legal consequences for companies that use this material. I suppose I bear some responsibility for not fully researching the mineral sources of each piece of electronics I buy, but the simple act of meeting consumer demand is not morally neutral. Putting legal pressure on companies to not use material mined by children could be helpful (with the usual caveat wrt the devil & details.)
No worries... i don't think forcing companies to stop buying will help the child labourers, but i do think it's the least we can do in the west.

Troubling times we live in.

I blame the tech companies because part of the product is hiding the reality that produces it. If a cell phone had a picture of a kid bleeding in a mine, like a pack of cigarettes with a pair of black lungs, I think it would at least help transfer the responsibility to the consumer mentally.

My house has 6 computer monitors and I won't even say how many tv sets. I should be completely aware of how much that cost in earth and human but I got to feel smug by recycling the happy color cardboard it was wrapped with.