Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lgierth 2388 days ago
RMS has done terrible harm to our community
2 comments

maybe he has recently... but he is one of the founders of it.
The 80s were a long time ago
No, OSS predates Stallman.
Without RMS most of the software you are currently using wouldn't work. He has orthodox manners and is an extremist for freedom but "terrible harm" is a lie.
I am sure it would work just fine.
It mainly would not exist. Or if it did it would be very different.
What makes you think someone else would not step in instead? There was a similar argument when Ritchie died: "we would not have C, we would not have software". Well, maybe we would not have C, but for sure we would have (and already had) some other programming languages.
Most open source software wouldn't exist if it wasn't for proprietary software succesfully showing there is a market for it.
This is falling prey to the great man theory of history. How can you know that nobody else would have championed FOSS if not for him?

There are lots of FOSS advocates who were turned off to the whole movement because of him; what might they have done with him absent?

Sure, "copy-center" attitudes like those common in BSD communities would have prevailed, likely, and we'd have entered the shared-source/commons-licensing phase a decade earlier. Without the option of copyleft, an entire pillar of philosophy would be missing, but it likely would not matter, since the world would still be just as corporatist. The main thing missing in that world would be a belief that copyright can and will be changed in order to better suit the people.
I am still not getting that someone else would not come up with these or better ideas.
I think you underestimate the impact of GNU on your daily life. Sure, someone else might have made the same things, but in this timeline RMS did and by removing him, most of the software you are currently using falls apart.
Not true at all. I intentionally use BSD licensed software. Open Source predates GNU and would exist just fine without it.
From what I hear, it was actually RMS who originally convinced the BSD people to release their software, i.e. to create the BSD licence. I can’t remember where I read this, though, and I can’t find it now.
You mean the 98% of people world wide that doesn't use GNU software?