Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by staktrace 2402 days ago
I've often thought along these same lines (c.f. Asimov's Galaxia concept) but I think that this one-ness will inherently be limited by distance. Thoughts can be propagated across a planet pretty quickly but if we become a multi-planet civilization I would expect each planet to have it's own "one mind" (or whatever you want to call it) simply because of communication latency.
1 comments

Thought doesn't have mass. I see no reason to discount superluminal communication.
Superluminal communication breaks causality regardless of whether mass is involved, and we have no evidence that effects can happen before they are caused.
Fair point. Another argument in favor of multiple one-ness is that of monocultures. In general things that become a monoculture are more vulnerable to sudden death. For long term survival diversity is good, and I imagine that planet-level conciousnesses would spawn daughter conciousnesses as they expand to other planets. Those daughter conciousnesses would further evolve and reproduce rather than being strongly tied to the parent.
Photons don't have mass either. Yet they cannot exceed the speed of light.
Are you sure about that? Bits have mass.
The underlying substrate on which bits register has mass but do they?
There are more electrons in your RAM if you set bits to 1.