Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Cthulhu_ 2408 days ago
How is that different from the US having fuck knows how many migrants (and children) in concentration camps, or "terrorists" in concentration camps, or slaves in overcrowded prisons, etc etc etc.

I mean not specifically you, but why are people in these comments all moral policing a country halfway across the world while their own is just as bad?

2 comments

The migrants, while in a terrible plight, are technically coming into a foreign country without following the proper process. They're suffering a (deeply problematic) government response to that action, essentially a poorly done catch and deport process.

China is systematically doing this to its own citizens, and intentionally harvesting body parts from them.

Those are, in fact, quite different.

China is

It's not even close to the same.

> fuck knows how many

~38,000 [1]

> migrants (and children) in concentration camps

People who violated immigration law. (Also, many are free to leave, via voluntary departure.)

> "terrorists" in concentration camps

People who violated international law.

> slaves in overcrowded prisons

People who violated federal or state law.

---

In particular, those laws do not prohibit religious faith or speech.

I'd suggest a closer analogy to the Muslim re-education centers would be Japanese internment facilities in the U.S during the 1940s.

--

[1] https://bipartisanpolicy.org/blog/immigration-detention-in-t...