Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by croon 2398 days ago
Might concern some users:

I had an issue on my 250/250Mbps-line using speedtest-cli in that it showed the correct download speed, but only 4Mbps upload.

Googling suggests it could be an issue with slow CPU/low RAM.

My (now old) server was by no means a beast as it had a throttled i3-3220T with 8GB RAM, but it should be plenty fast for that task.

The solution I came across on reddit/stack was to use this [0] instead, which solved the discrepancy for me:

[0] https://github.com/taganaka/SpeedTest
2 comments
mfontani 2398 days ago
Indeed, my own raspberry pi was returning weird results with the python-based one; I switched to this one and it is more consistent. I had to add an "--output json" option to it to not have to redo all my tooling around tracking the speedtest results, but forgot to make a pull request to the repo, and I've just done that: same json format as the python-based version.
link
milankragujevic 2398 days ago
Thank you! You're awesome!

I used to use speedtest-cli to monitor my Internet speed regularly, in fact every 5 minutes, while also logging DOCSIS signal levels, when debugging connection issues.

It didn't give accurate results, and that caused problems for me.

I wanted to switch to the C++ version, but needed the JSON output to be able to log the data and analyze it.

link
walrus01 2398 days ago
a raspberry pi 3/3b+ or whatever (not v4) should by no means be used for any sort of speed test, not only is the wifi weak/slow but the wired ethernet interface is also hanging off a usb2.0 bus.
link
Fnoord 2398 days ago
> A raspberry pi 3/3b+ or whatever (not v4) should by no means be used for any sort of speed test

You make a valid point though you could test the speed of the Raspberry Pi in question. As long as you take the caveats you mentioned into account, that's an OK context. Which is the problem with GP's post to begin with.

link
mfontani 2398 days ago
My pi is connected directly to the router via ethernet, and the bandwidth available to my home connection isn't enough to saturate it "unfortunately" (~95/20) so this isn't massively a problem for me. YMMV.
link
Symbiote 2398 days ago
With the Ubuntu packaged version 2.0.0:

  Testing download speed...
  Download: 917.52 Mbit/s
  Testing upload speed...
  Upload: 4.16 Mbit/s
Yeah, there's something wrong with that. There doesn't seem to be high CPU use.

Version 0.3.4, which is the default from Apt on a test server, seems to be OK:

  Download: 2239.51 Mbit/s
  Upload: 882.54 Mbit/s
(Maximum would be 20Gbit/s both ways, but I suspect achieving that to a single server would require some network parameter tweaking.)
link