[cwkoss]

Snowden demonstrated that the "technical whistleblower" channels are ineffective at ending illegal behavior by the govt.

The assertion that whistleblowers must use official channels is just a paper-thinly veiled argument for silencing all whistleblowing.

[jeremyfranco]

I'm more inclined to think that Snowden and Manning case prove that whistleblowing it's effective only if the receiver is good at protecting the source, which wikileaks, and Assange in particular, is not.

Deep throat identity has been a very well kept secret for over 30 years, Manning and Snowden have been exposed merely weeks after the material was published.

It looks to me that Wikileaks is the real paper-thinly veil.

If I was a conspiracy theorist I would think that wikileaks was created exactly with the purpose of exposing whistleblowers.