[rowanG077]

No we aren't at "House on fire" state yet. Once people start dying en masse and wars are breaking out over liveable land and resources is when we have reached "House on fire" territory.

We are currently at we know we have an electrical problem in the walls that we know will cause a house fire in the future if we don't fix it.

[MayeulC]

> We are currently at we know we have an electrical problem in the walls that we know will cause a house fire in the future if we don't fix it.

I disagree. Permanent damage has already been dealt. To continue with the house analogy, we can probably still save a smaller or bigger part of it depending on how quick we are to put the fire down.

But irreversible damage has already been done: even if we were to stop our carbon emissions right away, sea levels would still rise quite a bit (more than 1m by 2100-2300 IIRC). Every species that goes extinct will stay extinct, forever. And many are headed down this path. Biodiversity has suffered a lot in many places.

Think about this: we can complain about having to deal with radioactive garbage in 100ky, but any species that disappears today will not come back, even after billions of years. And millions of would-be species from its possible ofspring won't ever be either.

Those thoughts put things in perspective. I find them daunting, and this has led a lot of people to take the "climate emergency" very seriously. Our house is already on fire. Even if we start putting it out, we know it will still continue growing at least for a bit after we start pumping water, but we'd better start ASAP.

[svara]

Attibuting any specific catastrophic event to climate change is hardly possible, though. Arguably, climate change is already playing a role in conflicts around the world. The arab spring (and therefore the ongoing war in Syria) was partly triggered by discontent over food prices, which are of course closely linked to the local weather and thus climate change. Here's an article that explores this is some more detail:

https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/conflicts-affected-...

[rowanG077]

That is a localized conflict. It really is a problem once the entire world is touched. If global warming will not result in large scale wars and people dying en masse it's not really a problem. It would mean global warning would only entail a reduction in quality of life not large enough to warrant violence.

Even if global warning has a death toll of 10% of the world population I don't consider that a real problem. As long as humanity can progress afterwards it's fine.

[dTal]

>Even if global warning has a death toll of 10% of the world population I don't consider that a real problem.

Absolutely incredible. Are you picturing your friends and family in this hypothetical 10% death toll? Or the social conditions that would result in this number (comparable to Germany in WW2)?

What is so horrifying to you about stopping global warming, that literally decimating the world's population is the less bad option?

[rowanG077]

I never said it wouldn't be horrible. But let's be honest the human species lived on after WW2. I'm not sure where you got that I think that stopping global warming is horrifying, I don't think I ever said that. Beside that point that is not what I believe.

I think it would be great if we could stop global warming. But I don't think it socially possible. The only glimmer of hope I have left is that it is only a significant reduction of the human population while the rest can move on.

[dTal]

No, mass death and wars would be "you are currently dying in the fire". There is a fire, it has already destroyed many things, but it hasn't yet reached the sofa, where we are currently sitting complacently.

[rowanG077]

"You are currently dying in the fire" Would be humanity is extinct. Mass death and wars don't mean humanity is doomed.

[dTal]

No, extinction would be "you have died in the fire". "Mass deaths" is what the process of going extinct looks like.

[rowanG077]

I'm not sure where you are from but in my reality you don't really bounce back when you are dying in fire.