Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by grumpydba 2408 days ago
It's the first of its generation and is quite a failure on many aspects. It's not representative of all the nuclear reactors in France, far from it. Thus it is quite insignificant.
3 comments

In many ways Germany's renewable infrastructure was first of its kind, because Germany paid for the entire industry to get kickstarted.

Just like semiconductors needed ridiculously overpaid government contracts to get started at the beginning of Silicon Valley, solar needed a massive government funded effort to kick start the beginnings of the industry.

And unlike nuclear, which never got cheaper as we built more, solar is plummeting in price on a consistent schedule.

And whether or not it is a first of kind, the estimated for the FOAK build were wildly off and inaccurate, whereas with solar, Germany knew exactly the amount of financial risk they were taking by buying high.

> It's the first of its generation and is quite a failure on many aspects. It's not representative of all the nuclear reactors in France, far from it.

It's the only new one, based on designs of early 90s and earlier. The others are mostly all old and many with completely outdated designs from the 70s. Many wouldn't survive the crash of a larger airbus or boeing aircraft.

That's the problem. Nuclear reactors are huge undertakings and obviously producing only one is going to be incredibly expensive, just like building only one wind turbine of a design. That's why countries should cooperate to build more continuously and more efficiently.
Countries should cooperate to phase out fossil and nuclear fuels and instead invest that money into expanding the power grid and into power storage.
I don't judge a software on an alpha release.
Alpha release software is not for production.
It isn’t software
To stay in France, it's a bit as if you said the cathedrals construction was a total failure basing your judgment on the Beauvais cathedral which also suffered of the second system effect.
But solar failure rate and cost will never go down?