Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ryanwaggoner 2408 days ago
It’s ironic to talk about how corporations cause destruction in people’s lives in a way governments don’t, and then bring up hundreds of deaths as an example. Those deaths are tragic to be sure, but how many tens of millions of people have died at the hands of their governments in the last century?
2 comments

I dont think counting deaths caused by dictators addresses my point.

How do we make it an apples to apples comparison? For example,today, 2 million people a year die from air pollution, who is to blame for those deaths?

What about drug cartels, do we count the deaths that occurred in fighting them 'against' government? But if the government did not exist, those deaths would be higher, so do we count 'prevented deaths'? What about tabacco, etc. I dont think a realistic tally can be made.

Equating Stalin and the DMV is the kind of category error that prevents Americans from having good service at the DMV.
You’re the only one making such a comparison
You left an open-ended question, so you can't now complain that people interpreted it differently than what you intended.