Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by AnimalMuppet 2430 days ago
In that alternate history, I don't think that the subsistence farmers would be middle class.

That doesn't mean that I think the US was in the right. I don't. But it does not follow that all the problems in Guatemala are our fault.
1 comments
khrbrt 2430 days ago
They would be making closer to 3000 every two months instead of 300. It wouldn't be a utopia, but it'd be a lot better than if we hadn't bled Latin America dry for our benefit.

My point is that a factory moving overseas isn't some platonic transaction. There is a history and a context to why labor is so cheap and regulations are so lax.

link
AnimalMuppet 2430 days ago
How, in your world, would they be making closer to 3000 every two months?

[Edit: Forming unions doesn't automatically lead to rising wages - or if it does, it may do so at the price of fewer jobs. It isn't automatically going to lead to all the subsistence farmers getting good-paying factory jobs.]

> There is a history and a context to why labor is so cheap and regulations are so lax.

In Latin America, perhaps. In China? Korea, back in the day? Vietnam?

link