Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Andrew_nenakhov 2433 days ago
No. That's not how it works.

From the Apple Developers Documentation [1], "On initial launch of your app on a user’s device, the system automatically establishes an accredited, encrypted, and persistent IP connection between your app and APNs."

This persistent connection is, in fact, an XMPP session (likely, a modified one) [2].

Google's FCM too uses XMPP [3].

[1] https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Ne...

[2] https://www.quora.com/What-technology-does-the-iOS-Apple-Pus...

[3] https://firebase.google.com/docs/cloud-messaging/xmpp-server...
1 comments
icedchai 2432 days ago
If you look at the format of APNS messages, they are nothing like XMPP. It seems very unlikely Apple uses it. That link you post does not confirm it.
link
Andrew_nenakhov 2432 days ago
Format of APNS messages is just a payload. The information about APNS being based on XMPP was widely available on developer.apple.com and was often mentioned in developer sessions in 2010..12 when I was actively following it.

The current absence of direct XMPP mentions on Apple Deveoper website might mean that they consider their internal technology not important for developers, or it might mean that Apple had changed the protocol for some reason (they could have opted to use some binary protocol, for example), but claiming that push notifications work on iOS devices by polling servers is beyond ridiculous. VoIP pushes arrive in ~1 second. Such response times would require 40000 poll requests/day or more

link
icedchai 2432 days ago
I never claimed APNS worked by polling. I was developing iOS apps in the 2010-2012 time frame and never saw a mention of XMPP. I simply don't believe they are using it. They must have their own proprietary solution.
link
Andrew_nenakhov 2431 days ago
> I never claimed APNS worked by polling.

I was referring to earlier comments by nicolas314, sorry if it wasn't clear.

> I was developing iOS apps in the 2010-2012 time frame and never saw a mention of XMPP

I might have been more attentive to these details because XMPP was relevant for my projects. Anyway, Apple definitely does use port 5223 [1][2] for push notifications. What protocol is known to use this port?

Speaking of proprietary, it is very likely that they have modified it (by stripping it down, mostly). Many XMPP features are excessive or inefficent for push notifications, but core functions - message routing and persistent TCP connection are extremely well suited for serving several billion devices.

[1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT203609

[2] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210060

link