Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by paulgb 2449 days ago
It's really great for travel. I can bring one charger that works for my phone, my MacBook, and my work PC.

Ironically, one of the reasons I went with Android instead of iPhone last time I bought a phone was that I could use my MacBook charger with it.

4 comments

I charge my iPhone 8 with a USB-C to Lightining cable connected to the MacBook's power adapter

Sure, you have 1 more cable to throw in your bag but it's not a big deal.

And some cameras (e.g. Canon EOS-RP)
That thing charges my phone in 30 minutes
Is it safe? Most fast charging android phones have 18W chargers, and Macbook has 45 to 60W charger.
Fast charging depends on the compatibility with certain standards (USB-PD or Qualcomm Quickcharge). If it can't communicate that it resorts to the default, which is 5v/0.9A or 4.5W.

So you would need compatible cables to make fast charging work, and then it will only fast charge up to 80% and then slow down.

USB-PD is the standard for power delivery and Apple (and Google) both rely on that, so if it's USB-PD compatible it'll support the quickest charging it can handle.

Don't you need to be really careful with which chargers you use with each device, regardless of the cable type? Pretty sure USB-C headphones shouldn't be charged with a USB-C Macbook Pro wall charger.
> Pretty sure USB-C headphones shouldn't be charged with a USB-C Macbook Pro wall charger.

Unless explicitly negotiated by both ends, every USB-C charger outputs the same boring 5 volts as classic USB, so the headphones should charge just fine.

The major exception to this is the Nintendo Switch that, due to shit design on Nintendo's part, can asplode itself.
The Switch dock had some implementation issues but they didn't break anything.

The only time things break is when you attach a broken charger that outputs 9 volts onto a wire that's supposed to be doing 2 volt signals.

Only when used with another fault charger, which basically are extinct now.
Switch charges just fine from a MacBook power adapter. The issues are hugely overblown.
What's the problem with it?
They are wrong. The Switch console itself is USB-C standard compliant. The dock has a slightly smaller plug to make it easier to dock / undock the console. 3rd parties try to replicate the smaller plug but don't get the tolerances right causing a miswiring.
I can’t charge my phone with the Nintendo Switch charger, it switches on and off repeatedly and doesn't charge. And my other USB-C chargers don't negotiate the power needed with the Switch so it charges very slowly if you don't use the included charger.
> Pretty sure USB-C headphones shouldn't be charged with a USB-C Macbook Pro wall charger.

That should be fine. There's a protocol for the charger and the device to communicate and decide what power to charge at.

Chargers - no. Cables can be a problem tho.

Also some devices don't support anything else but USB-A to C cable that comes in a box. That's why I returned JBL Charge 4 and got Anker Soundcore Motion+. Much crispier stereo sound at expense of some base.

In spec devices will not have any issues. At worst your device will charger slower than it could.

Unfortunately a lot of devices are out of spec like the Nintendo switch which can be damaged by an in spec charger.

To be fair USB chargers weren't universal, either. I have a JBL Bluetooth speaker that I can't charge with any charger except the one that came with it