Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gamblor956 2444 days ago
Your misreading the ruling. It considers the forked coins to be new coins. However they're not income until actually received in your exchange account.

The cost basis of the new coins is $0 because you paid nothing to acquire them. If they have value when received for some reason, they take on the value you claim as income in your tax return. This may be possible if for example other exchanges have already enabled transactions in that fork and established a value.
1 comments
nullc 2444 days ago
> However they're not income until actually received in your exchange account.

What exchange account? -- yes, many (IMO foolish) users keep coins in exchanges, many don't. :)

I'd love to read it the way you're reading it.

> The cost basis of the new coins is $0 because you paid nothing to acquire them.

The document states:

> When a taxpayer receives property that is not purchased, unless otherwise provided in the Code, the taxpayer’s basis in the property received is determined by reference to the amount included in gross income, which is the fair market value of the property when the property is received.

So I guess you'd take the position that if you got access to the coins at the instant of the fork, when there is no FMV yet, then you'd report $0 income and have a $0 cost basis. Otherwise, if your access was delayed and there was a FMV, you'd treat that as income and it would become your cost basis?

link
gamblor956 2444 days ago
What exchange account? -- yes, many (IMO foolish) users keep coins in exchanges, many don't. :)

Doesn't matter, only that you use an exchange for the guidance to apply. If you receive the coins directly, this guidance isn't really relevant.

So I guess you'd take the position that if you got access to the coins at the instant of the fork, when there is no FMV yet, then you'd report $0 income and have a $0 cost basis. Otherwise, if your access was delayed and there was a FMV, you'd treat that as income and it would become your cost basis?

Yes, correct. If the forkcoin is worth $X at the time of receipt, you are taxed on $X income because your cost basis at the time is $0. But because you were taxed on $X, your cost basis is set to $X.

link