[DoreenMichele]

If you have a lot of images with white backgrounds, that's going to defeat the purpose of Dark Mode.

Some people prefer dark mode because they suffer migraines and bright lights are a problem when they have a migraine. Or homeless people may be using it for both stealth purposes and battery conservation when they have limited opportunities to recharge.

For some people, this preference is not just some minor detail. It's a much more important thing than "I just happen to like dark color schemes."

[saagarjha]

> Or homeless people may be using it for both stealth purposes and battery conservation when they have limited opportunities to recharge.

Sorry, what? I feel like this is a very contrived reason to support dark mode in your interface, if it even helps…

[DoreenMichele]

Contrived: deliberately created rather than arising naturally or spontaneously. Synonym: deliberate

created or arranged in a way that seems artificial and unrealistic. Synonym: forced

----

People can do anything they want with their websites. I'm not anyone who sets global policy on what your website should do.

But there's nothing contrived about the comment. It's an unplanned, spontaneous thought based on first-hand experience.

I spent nearly six years homeless. I'm quite open about that. I still blog about homelessness.

I spent a lot of time online while homeless. This was written about me:

http://alexandralindelof.com/story-package/

[saagarjha]

I'm aware of that, but images on a website being desaturated or having a dark background doesn't seem like it would help. (I do agree with your appeal to those who are sensitive to bright lights, FWIW. It's just that this one sounds like a bit of a reach.)

[DoreenMichele]

If you are illegally camped in a dark field and your phone, tablet or laptop is the only source of light, bright white images emit much more light that can give away your position than dark ones.

IIRC, the two primary things we did to conserve battery power were 1. Avoid certain games and 2. Turn down screen brightness.

In ordinary usage, the screen on our tablets was typically the biggest drain on the battery. This was especially true for tablets with a large screen.

I don't have (anec)data specific to dark mode on websites and power usage. I just know that using our devices carefully was the difference being kept occupied for three or four hours until we could sleep or running out after an hour and having nothing to do but talk, which is not a stealthy activity.

[qplex]

"As an example, one commercial QVGA OLED display consumes 0.3 watts while showing white text on a black background, but more than 0.7 watts showing black text on a white background, while an LCD may consume only a constant 0.35 watts regardless of what is being shown on screen."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMOLED

[cerberusss]

The citation was from 2009. I expect, or rather hope, that things have improved. Interesting link, by the way, and very useful to add to the discussion.

[DoreenMichele]

So it depends on the display and may become a thing of the past.

That's really good info.

[danjac]

What about browser addons like Dark Reader? Would that make more sense than relying on thousands of sites to have a reliable dark mode (when the vast majority won't support any kind of dark mode anyway)?

[DoreenMichele]

I was internet acquainted for a time with someone suffering chronic migraines. She said she could not do anything with browsers most of the time and switching her phone to dark mode was a problem because it just flipped the colors for everything.

She spent her time on Twitter because it has a terrific dark mode. She couldn't get other things to work for her.

So people who are very photophobic are apparently not finding adequate accommodation for their needs. I poked around a bit after talking to her and confirmed that her criticisms were valid. The current available options don't work well for trying to surf the internet under such constraints.

I'm not advocating that anyone do anything in particular. I'm just talking about use cases I have a little knowledge of. That's it.

[danjac]

Sure. I'm wondering whether something like Dark Reader - i.e. an addon or even as a standard browser feature - might be more helpful to people who genuinely need dark mode everywhere, rather than trying to persuade thousands of site owners and designers to individually provide some kind of dark styling (and as is apparent in the thread, not doing so perfectly, e.g. with images).

[dageshi]

Do you not think maybe that people with migranes and homeless people conserving battery might be edge cases just a little bit too far to worry about?

Because I do. And I'm someone who runs permanent dark mode via plugins in firefox due to eye strain/headaches. I don't expect the world to bend over backwards and I certainly don't expect people to recolour image backgrounds for me. The plugins do a good enough job.

[DoreenMichele]

In the U.S., more than 38 million people have migraine disease, with some estimates suggesting that this number may be even higher, impacting as many as 50 million or more. Some migraine studies estimate that 12 percent of adults in the U.S. population have migraine, and 4 million have chronic migraine.

https://migraine.com/migraine-statistics/