Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by TheDong 2459 days ago
You're arguing against a strawman because you misunderstood the parent comment.

The character limit was only referring to the subject line. Under it you can have as many lines of additional context as you wish. That's the normal way; the subject is brief, the message is arbitrarily long.

For what it's worth, the linux kernel limits it to around 70 chars and uses a subsystem prefix, so clearly that can work on large long-lived complex projects.

Your argument against 50 characters in the entire message, including the body, is not one anyone would ever argue for, so you've constructed a complete strawman.

1 comments

And some useful context: the 50-character limit is the result of the subject lines then being readable next to a commit graph that Git can display.