[pedasmith]

Essentially, all your numbers are subtly wrong and all of their wrongness is making the final number look much larger. You have to adjust for inflation, including 'weird' inflation. You have to account to suddenly becoming disabled after 20 years. Including the employer contribution is arguably misleading.

Social security is security: no matter how I get screwed, I'm only poor when I'm old, not poverty stricken and dead.

[MuffinFlavored]

I think you might be right. Could you please rerun them with inflation accounted for just to make sure I didn't miss anything?