Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by methodover 2471 days ago
Gofast is just a weather balloon.

https://youtu.be/PLyEO0jNt6M

Gimbal is a jet. The perceived rotation is an artifact of the camera rotating on a gimbal.

https://youtu.be/4X1PRDbtiF0

Nimitz is also a jet. It’s far away, and blurry.

https://youtu.be/s1oTg0kxzDs

It would be really cool if these were alien spaceships. They’re likely not.

1 comments

It's interesting to see you speak matter-of-factly about what they are, despite the Navy saying they are indeed unidentified.
For a military, "identifying" a craft is less about saying what something is, and more about saying who something is. If you know that something is a jet, but you can't recognize the make of it well-enough to know whose embassy to complain to for it being in your airspace, then it's still "unidentified."

It's sort of like a criminal investigation. If you know that "a tall, Caucasian male" is responsible for the crime, that's not worth issuing a formal finding about, because you still haven't identified a suspect to pursue. You have some details, but not enough to "go on."

(Also, many things that aren't jets try to pretend to be jets in various ways, many jets try to pretend to not be jets in various ways, and many jets try to pretend to be other jets in various ways. If you just see "a jet", you can't be sure which of these cases is in play. Identification involves finding a non-repudiable signature—a tell that indicates a particular make of device, that cannot be faked by any other currently-known device. Sort of like a (well-made) virus signature.)

> For a military, "identifying" a craft is less about saying what something is, and more about saying who something is.

Except that the article says:

> And while officials said they don't know what the objects are