Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by walrus01 2480 days ago
Thankfully we seem to have standardized on plug type doors, not outward opening ones, since the dc10 disaster. I wonder what happened.

Considering emergency exit doors, cargo doors and primary boarding doors are all plug design it must have been a serious failure.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_DC-10#Cargo_...

2 comments

This is pure ignorance on my part, but do plug type doors seal as strongly when on the ground ?
There is a mechanical latch, but they seal much better once the aircraft is pressurized and the door is being pressed into the frame.

If you look at the windows on a research submersible, the Plexiglas windows are cone-shaped and placed facing the opposite direction from those on a plane, as the pressure there is coming from the outside. Same reason - the cone shape means the pressure differential creates a tighter seal as it becomes greater.

Story time: I was once on a Northwest flight, and a passenger in the exit row behind me called a flight attendant back while we were still loading. It seems she could put her arm out of the aircraft through a gap in the over-wing door opening. Sure enough, I look out my window and there's her hand waving back at me. They call a mechanic who reseals the exit (applying a new safety-wire seal) and off we go to our destination.

It almost certainly would have sealed shut once we got to altitude. And probably did for some unknown number of flights before she discovered the problem. But I definitely felt better once it had been repaired.

One would presume this is purely a function of the pressure differential between the cabin and environment, which they presumably controlled for.
Doesn't sound like it.

"Engineers had the plane pressurized and on the ground. They loaded it up well beyond capacity and bent its wings in an extreme manner..."

I was responding to a question about the difference between being on the ground and in the air, not one about the many other differences between this test and real-world operation.
They are plug doors, as with all other passenger jet airliners today. The door goes in at an angle (eg. 737) or part of it slides up/down (eg. 777) to fit through the door frame.