Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by imglorp 2480 days ago
(I'm the hell no commenter).

I probably should have stated that more kindly. I love the idea and I love that you've brought it here for comment.

The "hell no" comment comes from experiencing the dark pattern of requiring an email before the user can determine if there's any value. This pattern has been abused time and again, and many people will just leave without learning what it's about before giving out an email for another marketing push. I did, and maybe all the upvoters of that comment also. Even if the privacy terms are "no mail ever", that doesn't mean the DB won't be hacked or stolen some day, or the company simply sold and the DB harvested. Who knows. It's been spoiled by everyone before.

My suggestion is open it up so people can read all the project details. Perhaps require a signup only if the user wants to contact a poster. And consider not using email at all.

1 comments

yeah, the latest update would allow you to check out the project detail but requires you to signup if you want to participate. There is also an about page. ;)