Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by AnimalMuppet 2499 days ago
Here's the problem: Humans are not angels.

We, the people, we are not angels. So we need government to protect us from each other.

But those people in government? They aren't angels, either. So the trick is to have the government keep us from harming and oppressing each other, without the government harming and oppressing us. That was the point of the "limited government" idea, and the Constitution - government couldn't do everything; it could only do a few specific things. That is, they optimized for minimizing the harm government could do, rather than for maximizing the good.

And it's worked reasonably well, though not perfectly, even while government grew enormously compared to the original idea. Still, the fact remains that government is not run by angels. Those programs that you think are a good idea? Imagine that they're being run by selfish, foolish, corrupt people. Are they still a good idea? (Some may be. Surely not all, though...)

Reminding people of who the government works for may help, somewhat, for some time. But it won't really fix the problem.