From what I can assume, your difference is on whether they’d harm others. I’ll assume your creed is libertarian, though there are multiple essays where respected libertarian philosophers have argued that libertarianism doesn’t allow you to give up your liberties (e.g. suicide and indentured servitude)
The fact that these people could be talked out of their suicides (and in fact that some wanted someone to talk to lest they hurt themselves) shows they clearly were having a temporary lapse in judgement. If we accept utilitarianism as the basis of libertarianism, living another day with a clearer state of mind increases utility.
The moral code of "living fucking sucks". If somebody makes the choice to stop living, they should be allowed to fulfil thart choice instead of being stopped, forcibly or otherwise.
The last one is bad because those people unfortunately chose to live that day.
People who've made a firm decision that dying is the best thing for them to do don't call hotlines to get talked out of it. Nothing stopped any of those people from trying again later, either, if they decided that holding off had been the wrong decision. There's plenty of stories from people who e.g. jumped off a bridge but survived, who were filled with regret as soon as their feet left the platform. The fact is that suicidal impulses are often acute and transitory.
People should have the right to die, but you're basically saying that people shouldn't be allowed the option of talking things over with a sympathetic listener before making a final decision.
From what I can assume, your difference is on whether they’d harm others. I’ll assume your creed is libertarian, though there are multiple essays where respected libertarian philosophers have argued that libertarianism doesn’t allow you to give up your liberties (e.g. suicide and indentured servitude)
The fact that these people could be talked out of their suicides (and in fact that some wanted someone to talk to lest they hurt themselves) shows they clearly were having a temporary lapse in judgement. If we accept utilitarianism as the basis of libertarianism, living another day with a clearer state of mind increases utility.