Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vortico 2508 days ago
How large do you think the design space is?

Technically, it's enormous, maybe 8^15 possible melodies.

But what about good-sounding melodies? That drastically reduces the space.

What about memorable, good-sounding melodies? Most melodies aren't catchy, so that limits the space some more.

What about culturally-appropriate, memorable, good-sounding melodies? It likely wouldn't make sense to use a Turkish opera melody in a pop song. Genres typically encompass a small space of melodies (e.g. Blues, Boogie Woogie).

What about such melodies that follow a particular rhythm, or match the vocalist's range, or that follow a desired chord progression?

After all this is considered, you're probably down to only a million combinations. But there are a billion songs out there...

1 comments

the range of notes in pentatonic scale is only five. but the rhythms (the important part of modern music) have a lot more combinations. katy perry's writers used the exact same rhythm with the same notes, which is highly improbable