[paulsutter]

Your comments were misleading, even if you want to argue they were on point. I know that you're knowledgable about the kernel, I ready your other comments. The following comments are just not true, except in bizarro world where all code must be in the kernel:

- "Readahead... needs to be buffered"

- "reading unbuffered (ie. O_DIRECT)... you cannot read ahead"

Good application code needs to work around kernel limitations all the time. Your suggestion of fadvise is reasonable, except in practice fadvise rarely makes a measurable difference. The only way to get what you really want is to code it the way you want it, and fortunately, there are multiple ways to do that.