Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by headsoup 2513 days ago
You appear to be only referring to the retail side of Amazon, not the platform side where the article mentions Amazon has numerous restrictive practices in place and set the price through these by excluding competition and competing through their own retail lines, regardless of other (uncompetitive) options
2 comments

Amazon could drive companies within entire product sectors to bankruptcy simply by lowering the price of that product category on Amazon. The problem is that they can afford to do this in a sustainable way because they have so many other product lines.

When other big chains like Walmart do similar things, it does not have the same effect because people don't go to Walmart to buy just one item. Amazon is different; if they lower the price of an item, consumers react quickly and that can put other websites which specialize in that item out of business. Then when all major competitors within the item category are out of business, Amazon can increase the price to any amount it wants and use the extra proceeds to continue the process with different item categories.

> Amazon could drive companies within entire product sectors to bankruptcy simply by lowering the price of that product category on Amazon. The problem is that they can afford to do this in a sustainable way because they have so many other product lines.

Selling below cost can be illegal dumping. But do you have any evidence that they're actually doing that, rather than them merely negotiating a better price for it than you and then selling it with thin (rather than negative) margins?

> Then when all major competitors within the item category are out of business, Amazon can increase the price to any amount it wants

Notice that this only works if nobody is willing to reenter the market when the price increases, which is rarely the case. Otherwise they have to maintain the lower prices forever.

Choosing how much you're willing to pay for something isn't what "control prices" means. What it means is that if you offer to sell for more or buy for less by a significant amount, that won't cause your customers or suppliers to switch to a competitor. But that is what it would do with Amazon. People would go buy and sell using Walmart or a hundred other competitors instead.