Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lzol 2513 days ago
I feel like other engineering disciplines would function closer to the software world if it was easier to iterate. It is very difficult to nearly impossible to change the design of a bridge once construction has started.

If it was super easy, we'd very likely change things once they were in use. Perhaps we didn't account for pedestrians using the bridge and they're walking across it all the time or tractor trailers are having trouble making a right off the bridge. Software is inherently "soft". It's malleable. When done well, it can create better fit to purpose solutions than almost any other discipline. I agree that most "software engineering" is more like plumbing, but I do feel like "real" engineering disciplines would likely follow a similar paradigm if they had the same luxury to rework things.
2 comments
LanceH 2513 days ago
The development of the road system as a whole is very much iterative.
link
samstave 2513 days ago
Well, look at tooling... and in the bridge analogy; material selection.

Look at the bay bridge, we built it using steel from china which, after it was already being used to construct the span was later found to be inferior.

So in SW dev -- you might choose a tool for a massive project only to find its the wrong/not best tool you could have selected based on the budget at the time the project started.

This can also be said of the team. Employee A was the right eemployee at the start of the project, but they later prove to not be the best resource, but youre already X% down the project timeline... what do? Esp at what cost.

link
lzol 2513 days ago
I'm not arguing that that other forms of engineering are completely inflexible or that software doesn't have some constraints. I'm just saying that in general it is far, far easier to change lines of code than it is physical objects. That's why when there is a hardware issue that can be addressed in software, they send you a patch not a new CPU.
link
samstave 2513 days ago
We are in agreement.
link
C1sc0cat 2512 days ago
Or a surveying team missed some problems early on - and a bridge fell of its supports.

One Job I had (at a top 5 consulting engineer) was to reverse engineer the code from an onsite survey computer and build a GUI to analyse the data allow one of our Senior Engineers to look at what happened.

link