| Outlawing X doesn't mean almost-X is completely fine. That said, none of your examples make much sense (to me). > - autoplay of gifs vs web videos Presumably the content is what matters, not the particular compression format. Does it show animated content continuously without being triggered by active user interaction? Yes, so it's an auto-playing video. > - does Pinterest count as an auto scroll ad It's primarily focused on a call to action, so yes, it's an ad. Would they show an equivalent popup for ordinary user-generated content that they have no stake in? > - does an endless scroll populated with 50% real content count as non-ad? Is there an ad that appears when the user scrolls? I don't even see what this example was supposed to demonstrate. > The law will just create more headaches for the producers and less innovation thanks to having to fight lawsuits. More headaches and less innovation in how to sell bullshit sounds like a very positive outcome to me. |
By that logic a loading spinner is an auto-playing video. Does me logging in count as "active user interaction" for showing me a loading spinner? I didn't request the spinner, I requested access to my skype chats.