Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by p1esk 2523 days ago
I'm not against modeling aspects of the brain based on what we know, just don't call that "whole brain" simulation/model.
1 comments

What would you call SimCity if not a city simulator?
It's a city simulator, not specific city simulator or even close. It is not accurate either as accuracy was not the main goal, but fun.

Human brain is a very specific and complex brain which we do not understand - vastly less than even cities at any scale. And to produce any useful answers, the model has to be accurate to some degree - and we don't know how much. HBP indeed had no question which it tried to answer - it's more like climbing a mountain because it exists.

I have no problem with calling SimCity a “whole city” simulator. Why? Because we have a good functional model of a city. We understand its operation on any level. Not the case with the brain.