Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jstimpfle 2520 days ago
Yes, I realized the CPU issue and already updated my comment. Technically we would need a way to catch the CAS operation and convert it into a network request - like for example segfaults can be handled and converted into a disk load.

And also we'd need to extend all the cache coherency stuff over the network.

> And if you assume all your peers are reliable in a distributed system, you're wrong. Damned either way.

Technically you have the reliability issues with all the components inside a single system, just as well. They are just more reliable. But I'm sure I have seen hard disks failing, etc.

--

Ok, let me think about that abstraction stuff. Thanks.
1 comments
ori_b 2520 days ago
I'd also argue that if you need to turn a cache snoop into a network round trip (or several?), your abstraction is just as broken as if it returned the wrong value; it's unusably slow :)
link
jstimpfle 2520 days ago
Yes, that's why I'm still having trouble to understand the fuss about VFS abstraction as used in 9p etc ;-). I've always been glad to know when I was not on an NFS or sshfs mount (mostly for reasons that you can't design away, i.e. network reliability issues). So why bother abstracting out that knowledge even more?
link
ori_b 2520 days ago
When you come at it from the perspective that remote resources are the norm, and you assemble a computer from resources scattered across the network, local access becomes weird special case. Generally, you're running a file server and terminal as separate nodes, with an auth server somewhere else.

And if you're actually using the knowledge that some files are local, you get bugs and assumptions creep in, and now your software stops working in the case where you're running on someone else's network.

It's about transparently providing the same interface to everyone, and making that interface simple enough that implementing it is easy enough that it's actually done, and the interface actually gets used.

Then, if you want to interpose, remap, analyze, manipulate, redirect, or sandbox it, you can do that without much trouble. The special cases are rare and can be reasoned about.

Reasoning about your system in full frees you to do a huge amount.

link