Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by brownbat 2525 days ago
I want to be careful, this could get holy war-ish...

So I do not want to sell anyone on changing their view. This isn't advocacy. But just want to provide one illustration of why someone may prefer Fahrenheit.

When I travel, hotel rooms generally let me alter the temperature on digital thermostats by one degree. In the US, that's great, that's plenty of precision. In Europe, I lose fidelity and am strictly worse off.

If people like a room set at 71 degrees, they don't like 72 or 70. If they like it at 75, they aren't secretly shooting for 76.

When I'm cooking in an oven or sous vide, I often want to tweak controls very precisely in an attempt to balance the carmelization of sugars or the rendering of fats while leaving proteins or starches intact.

Room temps, weather, and cooking are the ways I mainly interact with these scales. In each of them, the precision of the base unit in F is strictly advantageous to me.

Celsius can absolutely allow greater granularity, if everyone used an extra significant digit as a rule. I blame psychology though, people and systems often just don't bother to think that way.

I wholly support the metric system to unify measurement across different scales. That's neat. But as I rarely need to talk about millidegrees or gigadegrees, it seems less relevant to me in this context.

4 comments

To somebody who lives in one of the few hundred countries that uses Celsius, this just seems like a non-problem... While a lot of air conditioners adjust in single degree steps, plenty exist that go up or down in half degrees. A sous vide would probably adjust with a single decimal point. Digital thermometers basically also always do also. My weather app says it’s 16.1 degrees C outside right now... Easy...

Your comment about psychology is actually just you mistaking familiarity with your temperature system with something more universal. In countries where we use metric/Celsius, we find decimals super easy to think in because we’re used to doing it!

Temperature sensors in thermostats are nowhere near as precise as you seem to believe. And unless you have calibrated your sous vide to a standard I am willing to bet good money its not anywhere within 1 degree precision (having tested this.. you’re lucky to get +/- 3 C). Also nothing in cooking requires the precision down to fractional degrees C. You’re not going to obtain it anyway, even if you think you are.

Everything you’re saying is all in your head.

The user interfaces let you input temperatures with more precision. But i would be astounded if the thermostats actually regulated the temperatures with that much accuracy. Have you tried measuring the temperatures actually attained?
What if I want 0.25 degree adjustments? Can we all make and use a scale that lets me do that? This is a non problem for most of the world’s population. And if it is a problem, we can fix it by creating thermostats that work in C and let you have half degree adjustments. That’s your billion dollar idea.