Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by michaelt 2526 days ago
I agree it's true metal conducts heat better than plastic, and that a metal package is a conventional choice for that reason.

I disagree that the thermal image provides evidence of those truths

Does the image prove the CPU has a low temperature? No, the image reports the temperature inaccurately. Does the image prove the package has no hotspots? No, it wouldn't show hotspots if they were there. Does the fact the PCB gets hot tell us much? Not really, you'd expect heat to conduct from the package and balls to the PCB no matter what the package was made from.

1 comments

If that cap didn't spreading the heat as well, what you'd be seeing on the thermal camera would be something that glows around 60C-70C (because clearly, the camera's software can more or less resolve the room temperature reflection from 60C thermal radiation), and the color would be more or less uniform in the region above the CPU. There wouldn't be such a strong observed temperature gradient.

Which is the evidence you're looking for.