[goto11]

But it is not some arbitrary historical accident that months are numbered from 1. It is the same reason the days of the month are numbered from 1. It is how ordinal numbers work!

Neil Armstrong was the 1st man on the moon - not the zero'th. Everywhere you have a sequence of discrete units, they are numbered starting from 1.

The thing with array indices in C is they are not ordinal numbers. They are offsets. Which means you can (at least in theory) do x[-1] to get the element before x. So a C array is not actually an array in the mathematical sense, it is just syntactic sugar for relative offsets in a larger array.

So what makes most sense? It really depends on what you want to achieve.