[kickout]

He was careful how he said it; thus the many disclaimers about being a fan of tidyverse in general. I think you are underestimating the effect of tidyverse being taught. Also, RStudio is absolutely free to push whatever packages they want. Same as R users in general are free to use any package they want. But if most people learn the tidyverse, thats invariably what they will default to whether people like it or not.

[throw20102010]

Sure, he puts the required disclaimers about respect in the beginning so that way he doesn't get accused of being hateful. But then he accuses RStudio of doing "an end run around the core R leadership team," and that what they are doing is "bad for the health of the project," which are pretty strong words.

RStudio isn't on the leadership team. If the language ends up dying (which it won't, R is dug into it's place like a tick), it would be due to the leadership team's refusal to adapt to good ideas coming in from the community.