Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by throwaway34241 2555 days ago
I've had these bulbs and done this reset process more times than I can count. For years the software was some of the worst I've ever used.

It would constantly lose pairing with the bulbs. In order to re-pair with the bulbs, all the bulbs had to be reset individually using this process, and then all configuration had to be deleted from the app and every bulb needed to be re-added as a new bulb. Pairing was error-prone. Firmware updates would constantly fail.

Not only that, but initially the software didn't even support turning them on or changing the color on a schedule, despite the hardware being capable of it (they added the feature later). If basic things like schedules don't work what is even the point of smart bulbs?

Looking at this error message from the app [1] might give you an idea of how sloppy their SW was. This isn't from the first version either.

After they added schedules it was a bit better since you could just set one and not touch it. And after years they've fixed some of the major bugs.

I still think smart lights are useful. Setting the lights to turn on in the morning (as a substitute for an alarm clock) is very nice, as well as changing to a warmer color temperature in the evening. But switches are superior to phones for just turning the lights on and off IMO. I think an ideal smart light system would use switches to turn them on and set brightness/color temperature, and only use the phone for advanced things like scheduling.

[1] https://imgur.com/a/Uauynh6

3 comments

Oh my goodness. Why did you put up with that for so long? Surely there are other bulbs that are just as capable and don't come with this ridiculous software.
Ikea's smart lights have some switch like buttons you can use to turn on and off the lights (you can also adjust the brightness by holding down the buttons). It's pretty nice to be able to just place those little buttons wherever you think you want to turn on the lights.
Maybe my Hue lights are not that expensive in retrospect.