Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by aiisjustanif 2553 days ago
> The rare exception

Stop. It's not rare, 6% is not rare [1]. 10 states have 10% and above, up to 26%. Emergency room visits happen quite often enough.

[1]: https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/emergency-room-vis...

4 comments

rare

adjective

(of an event, situation, or condition) not occurring very often.

I'd say 6% fits that definition. You're also ignoring the fact that, for various reasons, people show up in an ER when they really didn't need to.

This helps in the vast majority of cases and you're being needlessly argumentative.

If a policy helps 94% of the time and is no better or worse 6% of the time, should we enact it?
It's definitely rare. That's 6-10% of medical visits. Which tend to be made by a minority of people visiting very often.

In fact, to use that stat per 1000 people is not very useful.

Number of people per 1000 visiting a hospital for an emergency would be more helpful.

I suspect it would be much less than even 1%.

> Emergency room visits happen quite often enough.

Many ER visits often happen because people can't afford insurance and preventative care. If this alleviates some of that by permitting more competition due to price transparency, then it will become even more rare.

1 out of 20 people get appendicitis. Appendicitis a lot of the time is handled at the ER, due to its sporadic and eminent nature.