[juergbi]

Works fine here with 1st Gen Threadripper on ASRock X399 Taichi, running Linux. Some points:

* Not all motherboards support ECC, make sure to check before buying.

* Only unbuffered DIMMs are supported by Ryzen/Threadripper.

* According to motherboard vendors, Ryzen APUs do not support ECC. Ryzen Pro APUs do support ECC but those SKUs are typically not available in retail.

[Already__Taken]

I believe asrock are the only manufacturer that have come out and said yes we test that ecc will work it's just not a supported config. The others don't quite commit that far.

I have an asrock + unbuffered ECC ryzen 5 1500 setup. I've checked windows does indeed detect errors when induced.

[BeeOnRope]

Curious how you induced errors?

[toast0]

The common way is to reduce memory voltage or tighten the timings until things start failing. Alternatively, you could probably run rowhammer PoCs.

[flyinghamster]

ECC is also working fine for me on the X370 Taichi with a first-gen Ryzen 7.