Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by whatshisface 2559 days ago
The sum of all the money earned by all workers without a minimum wage is higher than with one. With a minimum wage you have one fry cook in your neighborhood making $100/hr and everyone else unemployed, without one you have 100 people making $2/hr each. More total money is given out in the second case, although I guess you can decide you'd prefer having the rich few if that's what you want (economics doesn't judge which outcome is better, it just tells you which outcome you will get).

Edit: numbers made up to illustrate the claim, not to provide evidence. This claim is a widely accepted principle that you can find in any introductory econ textbook.
1 comments
Goronmon 2559 days ago
Decrease that $100/hr to $10/hr and increase the 100 people making $2/hr to 1 million people making $2 an hour, that way you go from $10/hr in earning potential to $2million/hr. Just by getting rid of the minimum wage!

I can see why the minimum wage is such a bad idea, you are totally correct.

link
whatshisface 2559 days ago
Your example, although meant to show that the point was silly, can still serve to illustrate it. Imagine that for the vast majority of people, widgets are worth $3 each, but for one person they are worth $10 each (because he really likes them). Further, suppose that a widget takes an hour to make. With a minimum wage, one person can make $10/hour serving the one person who want widgets that badly, but without one it becomes profitable to open up an entire new market sector of mass-produced widgets for the common man.

You can change the numbers and the details, but the general principles of microeconomics will prefer the free market every time.

link
derekp7 2559 days ago
To carry that example further, you have many people that are willing to pay $3 per widget. But there are barriers to opening a widget factory, such that there is only one widget factory in town. And the owner of that factory only wants to pay worker 50 cents per hour, selling the widgets produced for $3.00. Now total money paid to workers is much lower than if minimum wage is set to $3.00

So the moral of the story is minimum wage should be raised to the point where total employment is still at an acceptable level.

link