Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bdamm 2560 days ago
However, a transmitter with enough power to signal earth would be too massive to get fast with a solar sail, given today's technology. Maybe a chipsat gets to 20% c, but no way a dish does.
2 comments

Found the wiki page for the project: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Breakthrough_Starshot

so it looks like they'd want to launch by 2036. In the 'technical challenges' section, it does mention that some technologies would have to be miniaturized sufficiently, but it doesnt really mention much about whether that technology has reached viable stages or not, or whether it's a realm they'd have to specifically research further.

So I guess maybe the technology doesn't exist today? Sounds like probably not, but maybe the near future -- or at least they expect it to exist by 2036.

It's worth noting this project has backing by some pretty influential folks, including Stephen Hawking when he was still alive.

What if the chipsat sends the signal to the chipsat behind it which sends the signal to the chipsat behind it which....

So that the signal can be relayed by a bunch of short range transmitters all the way back to earth

Probably requires a surprising amount of short range transmitters to be launched then. I wonder if a formula could be developed that relates the energy needed to place one large transceiver at a given distance versus the energy needed to place small transceivers all along that given distance.