Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by robenkleene 2556 days ago
Got it, yeah as long as we agree most programmers do use the command line. I actually agree that there are hypothetical ways a command line could almost always be replaced, but to me the important part is that most developers choose not to replace it. (And I’d argue that dependence on the command line is actually increasing overtime, with package management, version control, continuous integration, and modern editor features being implement on top of it.)

The question I pose then, is if these things are possible to do in other ways, and those other ways are better, why don't professional developers choose to use them? For example, why isn’t programming on an iPad popular? I.e., where these other methods are literally the only way to do programming on device? Using SSH to program entirely in a terminal is almost certainly more popular for professional developers than any other approach of programming on an iPad (using blog posts about how professional developers develop on an iPad as an indicator).
1 comments
pjmlp 2556 days ago
Because those blog posts are from UNIX devs trying to use iPads for UNIX like work.

This is how Apple devs actually do development on iPads.

- Swift Playgrounds

- Pythonista

- Continuous for C# and F#

- Lisping

- Raskell

- GLSL Studio

link
robenkleene 2556 days ago
I’m only interested in whether the majority of professional developers are able to ship software to their users. Is your stance that you can do that just fine with just the tools you listed and therefore professional developers don’t need the command line on iOS?
link
pjmlp 2555 days ago
I guess that I am not a professional developer, apparently.
link
robenkleene 2555 days ago
Haha, not sure about that, but you most certainly aren't the "majority of professional developers". Neither am I, that's a whole bunch of people who couldn't care less about how you or I want to work.
link
pjmlp 2555 days ago
Professional MacOS developers, before OS X was born, did not use a command line at all, so Photoshop was created by amateurs?

Same applies to developers on Amiga and AtariST, also less professional?

Or what about Windows developers, that hardly bothered with cmd.com, doing their scripting via VBScript/JSCript and everything else via Visual Studio, as it was common practice until PowerShell, with its PowerShell IDE sprung into existence, also a bunch of amateurs?

Don't judge professional developers on other platforms with UNIX glasses on.

link