Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wl 2555 days ago
I never liked the explanation for the crystal orb. Oh, Leonardo knew about optics, but he painted the orb naïvely to show some sort of miracle.
1 comments

Why don't you like that explanation? Leonardo was obsessed with detail, and he would study things intensely, it's not that much of a stretch.
Which is why you'd expect an orb painted by Leonardo to have the correct optics.
Wasn't the orb supposed to symbolize Jesus performing another miracle by not having the light warp the fabric?
That's exactly the argument I'm dismissing. It's not much of a miracle for the orb to transmit light as one would naïvely expect. Rather, it suggests that somebody didn't do their homework.