[kemitche]

Sure but is that a problem?

If the originally submitted guide is admittedly subjective, then it seems like sharing different subjective viewpoints (with reasoning) in HN comments is a great idea. If it's a subjective thing, I'd rather hear from several viewpoints before making decisions about how to handle my own tables.

[chrisseaton]

How can subjective advice be 'wrong' though? How can there be an 'issue' with what someone likes the look of?

[thatoneuser]

Well if you're posting it publicly and claiming "this is better" then you're either wrong or open to criticism.