Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sevenf0ur 2565 days ago
That second scenario has always fascinated me. What's the burden of proof for contempt of court? Forgetting a password seems plausible to me. Anyway, reminds me of this reddit post: https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/afib1/truecrypt_and_t...
1 comments

That's probably a made up story or at least not accurately told. That's not how the legal system operates.
Which part of the legal system isn't expressed accurately there? I'm asking out of my own ignorance, not as an accusation, I've only been a juror once.
It would be extremely unusual for an investigator to continue an interrogation after a direct request for an attorney.

The FBI wouldn't execute a search warrant and miss a bunch of drugs and drug paraphernalia.

You don't get jailed for obstruction on the say so of the FBI.

The Judge doesn't interrogate the defendant ever.

Like the guy in the OP you don't get to just refuse to provide the PW. The Judge would hold in contempt.

A Federal judge wouldn't order property held by the local PD returned. And why would they have it if the FBI conducted the raid and was doing the forensics?

Excellent explanation, thanks. The story was definitely suspect, but I entirely missed the FBI involvement at all. Why couldn't a federal judge order the return of property in a case? Is it a jurisdictional issue, i.e. if for some reason the local police had it, that would require a municipal judge?